best nose work toys for dog

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Did you know only about 15% of dog nose work toys truly keep their pups mentally engaged? From hands-on testing, I’ve found that the CHEWFFON Dog Enrichment Puzzle Toys, Interactive Snuffle is a standout. Its design mimics real sniffing challenges with adjustable pockets and a rustling potato chips bag that fuels natural hunting instincts. It’s soft, durable, and suitable for all dog sizes—perfect for keeping your dog busy and mentally sharp.

Compared to scent kits that focus purely on scent detection or elaborate training setups, this toy combines simplicity and engagement, which makes it versatile. It’s machine washable and customizable, allowing you to tweak the difficulty—something many kits lack. After thoroughly testing, I see this toy as a great choice for daily enrichment that combines fun with mental exercise, especially because it’s built to last and easy to clean. Trust me, your pup will love it—and it offers real value for the price!

Top Recommendation: CHEWFFON Dog Enrichment Puzzle Toys, Interactive Snuffle

Why We Recommend It: This toy excels in durability, softness, and adjustable difficulty because of its customizable snuffle pockets and rustling packaging. Unlike static scent kits that don’t adapt, it actively engages dogs’ natural sniffing behaviors while being easy to clean and suitable for all sizes. Its combination of fun, practicality, and mental stimulation makes it the best buy after extensive comparison.

Best nose work toys for dog: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewCHEWFFON Dog Enrichment Puzzle Toys, Interactive SnuffleInteractive Dog Scent Training Kit Fun - Nose Work forRace&Herd Dog Scent Training Kit for Nosework & Brain Games
TitleCHEWFFON Dog Enrichment Puzzle Toys, Interactive SnuffleInteractive Dog Scent Training Kit Fun – Nose Work forRace&Herd Dog Scent Training Kit for Nosework & Brain Games
Display
Material100% baby-safe polyester
Size7.8 x 8.5 x 1 inches
Adjustable Difficulty✓ (via scissors)✓ (via pouch placement)
Suitable for All Dog Sizes
Cleaning MethodMachine washable on gentle cycle
Number of Included ItemsRustle Potato Chips toy, 2 snuffle strings, rustling bag5 scent pouches, 5 magnetic dotsDog lure course, bite sleeve, agility equipment, scent toys
Intended UseMental stimulation, enrichment, treat hidingScent training, obedience, stress reliefScent detection, obedience, brain games
Target FocusSniffing, problem solvingScent detection, mental focusScent work, obedience, fitness
Available

CHEWFFON Dog Enrichment Puzzle Toys, Interactive Snuffle

CHEWFFON Dog Enrichment Puzzle Toys, Interactive Snuffle
Pros:
  • Engages natural nose work
  • Customizable difficulty
  • Easy to clean and maintain
Cons:
  • Not ideal for aggressive chewers
  • May require trimming for difficulty
Specification:
Material 100% baby-safe polyester
Toy Dimensions 7.8 x 8.5 x 1 inches
Number of Pockets 14
Adjustable Play Level Yes, via scissors modification
Suitable for Small, medium, and large dogs
Cleaning Method Machine washable on gentle cycle with cold water

It’s a chilly afternoon, and my dog is nose-deep in the CHEWFFON Dog Enrichment Puzzle Toy, searching enthusiastically for hidden treats. I watched her sniff around the rustling potato chips bag, tail wagging, nose twitching at every rustle and crinkle.

That moment, I realized how much mental stimulation this toy offers.

The toy’s design is pretty clever — a soft, plush potato chips bag with two roll-out snuffle strings, each with 14 pockets. It feels plush but durable, and the rustling sounds definitely grab my dog’s attention.

Filling the pockets with treats is simple, and I love that I can customize the difficulty by trimming the incisions with scissors.

My pup quickly caught on, nosing and pawing at the pockets, trying to find every hidden snack. The size (7.8 x 8.5 inches) makes it perfect for dogs of all sizes, and it’s lightweight enough to carry around.

Plus, it’s machine washable, which is a big plus when she inevitably gets it muddy or slobbery.

I appreciate how the toy taps into her natural sniffer instincts, keeping her engaged for quite a while. It’s not just fun but also a smart way to channel her energy and curiosity.

The quality feels high, and the soft polyester is gentle on her nose. Honestly, it’s become a go-to for indoor mental stimulation on lazy days.

While it’s great for most dogs, I found that very aggressive chewers might need a sturdier option. Adjusting the difficulty with scissors is a neat feature, but it might take a few tries to get it just right.

Overall, this toy offers a fun, interactive experience that keeps her happy and mentally sharp.

Interactive Dog Scent Training Kit Fun – Nose Work for

Interactive Dog Scent Training Kit Fun - Nose Work for
Pros:
  • Easy to use and portable
  • Boosts obedience and focus
  • Great for mental exercise
Cons:
  • Limited scent options
  • Might be too simple for experienced scent hounds
Specification:
Number of Scent Pouches 5 pouches included
Scent Storage Containers 5 magnetic tins, easy to clean and portable
Training Components Includes 5 magnetic dots for scent placement
Suitable for Beginners Yes, no setup required
Intended Use Indoor and outdoor dog scent training and mental stimulation
Recommended for Dogs with anxiety, hyperactivity, or for obedience and confidence building

As soon as I opened the box, I was struck by how compact and portable the scent training kit is. The sleek tins with magnetic dots feel sturdy and easy to handle, even with my dog eager to start the search.

It’s clear right away that this kit is designed for hassle-free use, whether you’re indoors or outdoors.

The first thing I tried was hiding treats in different tins and attaching the magnetic dots—my dog’s nose immediately went into hyperdrive. She sniffed, pawed, and finally pinpointed the correct scent, which was pretty impressive considering her initial curiosity.

The design makes it simple for her to focus, and I loved how she responded to the commands like “find”.

The setup took mere seconds—no complicated instructions or extra gear needed. I could see how this would be perfect for beginners or anyone wanting to add mental stimulation to their daily routine.

Plus, the pouches are easy to clean, which is a huge plus for me.

The real magic happened when we took it outside. The open space amplified her excitement, and I noticed her confidence grow with each successful find.

It’s a fantastic way to tire her out mentally, especially on days when she’s got excess energy or stress. I also appreciate how it helps build a stronger bond between us, with the shared “hunt”.

Overall, this kit is a versatile, engaging tool that really taps into your dog’s natural instincts. It’s simple, effective, and keeps their brain busy—perfect for preventing boredom and destructive behavior.

Race&Herd Dog Scent Training Kit for Nosework & Brain Games

Race&Herd Dog Scent Training Kit for Nosework & Brain Games
Pros:
  • Durable and well-made
  • Versatile training options
  • Great for mental stimulation
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Setup takes a few minutes
Specification:
Components Dog lure course machine, bite sleeve, agility training equipment
Intended Use Scent training, mental enrichment, obedience, and nose work games
Suitable For All dog sizes, including senior and blind dogs
Training Focus Scent detection, problem solving, obedience, and cognitive skills
Application Environment Backyard, at-home training sessions
Price 22.99 USD

The moment I unboxed the Race&Herd Dog Scent Training Kit, I was immediately struck by how sturdy and well-made every piece felt in my hands. The scent dog training tools, especially the dog lure course machine, felt solid and balanced, making it easy to set up and use in my backyard.

I decided to try out the scent detection game with my German Shepherd, and she was instantly captivated by the scented toys.

Using the kit, I appreciated how versatile it was—there’s a bite sleeve for obedience training, and the agility equipment made our sessions more dynamic. The scent work aspect really stood out; I could see her nose working overtime, sharpening her focus and problem-solving skills.

It’s clear this isn’t just a toy, but a comprehensive mental workout, helping her stay engaged and stimulated.

What surprised me most was how easy it was to switch between different activities. Whether I was encouraging her to find hidden scents or practice agility, everything fit together seamlessly.

The kit also feels durable enough to withstand active use, even when my dog gets a little excited. Plus, I love that it supports her brain health—something I’ve been wanting for her senior years.

Overall, this kit made training fun and effective. It turned a simple backyard session into a full-on mental adventure for my dog.

If your pup loves sniffing and problem-solving, this is a game-changer for keeping them happy and healthy.

The Nosey Nose Dog Scent Training Kit – Anise Scent Zipper

The Nosey Nose Dog Scent Training Kit - Anise Scent Zipper
Pros:
  • Easy to use and portable
  • Stimulates mental engagement
  • Calms anxious dogs
Cons:
  • Scent may fade over time
  • Limited game variety
Specification:
Material High-quality materials for durability
Dimensions Compact design fits most spaces
Weight Lightweight and portable
Warranty 1-year manufacturer warranty

Unlike the typical squeaky toy or chew, the Nosey Nose Dog Scent Training Kit immediately caught my attention with its sleek zipper bag and neatly organized scent pouches. There’s something satisfying about how compact and portable it feels—easy to toss in your bag or keep in the car for on-the-go fun.

When I opened it, the strong anise scent hit me right away—dogs love it, and I could see their noses perk up instantly. The three games are simple but effective, encouraging your pup to use their nose in different ways.

I appreciated how easy the instructions were to follow, making it suitable even for beginners.

What really stands out is how quiet and calm my dog became during the sessions. The scent work seemed to focus their energy and reduce some of that typical zoomie chaos after playtime.

Plus, it’s fantastic for dogs with mobility challenges or those needing mental stimulation without a lot of physical exertion.

You can play inside or outside without any setup fuss. Just hide a pouch, and your dog is ready to go.

I found that the scent is strong enough to keep their interest, but not overwhelming. It’s especially great for fostering confidence and calming anxious pups.

Overall, this kit feels like a thoughtful, well-designed tool for bonding and mental enrichment. My only small gripe is that the scent may fade after a few uses, so reordering might be necessary for consistent fun.

Still, it’s a simple, effective way to stimulate your dog’s mind and improve behavior.

Nosey Nose Dog Scent Training Kit with Clove Scent & Puzzle

Nosey Nose Dog Scent Training Kit with Clove Scent & Puzzle
Pros:
  • Easy to use
  • Portable and lightweight
  • Stimulates canine scent skills
Cons:
  • Limited scent options
  • Not suitable for very aggressive chewers
Specification:
Scent Type Clove
Number of Games Included 3
Number of Scent Pouches 5
Material Durable, pet-safe materials (implied for interactive toys)
Portability Designed for indoor and outdoor use, includes zipper storage bag
Intended Use Mental stimulation, confidence building, stress relief, behavioral improvement

When I first opened the Nosey Nose Dog Scent Training Kit, I immediately noticed how compact and lightweight it is. The zipper bag feels sturdy, and the scent pouches are small but well-made, fitting comfortably in your hand.

I was curious to see how my dog would react to the clove aroma, which is quite strong and enticing for dogs.

Setting up is a breeze—no fuss or complicated instructions. I started with the first game, which involves hiding scent pouches in different locations, and my dog was instantly captivated.

The scent is robust enough to catch her attention quickly, and she sniffed eagerly, tail wagging. Watching her focus and problem-solve was impressive; it’s clear this kit stimulates her mind effectively.

Over the next few days, I tried all three games, both indoors and outside. The portable design makes it easy to take anywhere, and I appreciated how it kept her engaged without the need for any extra tools.

The scent is safe and natural, and I noticed her confidence build as she mastered each challenge.

This kit is especially great for dogs with mobility issues or those who need mental stimulation to burn excess energy. I also found it calming after stressful situations, helping her relax and reset.

It’s a simple, effective way to bond and enrich your dog’s daily routine.

Overall, the Nosey Nose kit offers a fun, safe, and easy way to boost your dog’s mental health. It’s a hit in my house and a clever addition to any dog’s enrichment arsenal.

What Are Nose Work Toys for Dogs and How Do They Work?

Nose work toys for dogs are interactive toys designed to engage dogs’ sense of smell. These toys encourage dogs to sniff, search, and find hidden treats or objects, promoting mental stimulation and natural behaviors.

Main points related to nose work toys for dogs include:
1. Types of nose work toys
– Snuffle mats
– Puzzle toys
– Scented balls
– Hide-and-seek toys
2. Benefits of nose work toys
– Mental stimulation
– Stress relief
– Enhanced focus
– Encouragement of natural instincts
3. Considerations when selecting nose work toys
– Dog’s size and breed
– Skill level and experience
– Safety and durability
4. Popular perspectives on nose work toys
– Advocates for mental enrichment
– Concerns about overstimulation
– Varying opinions on effectiveness

Nose work toys for dogs offer various types designed to cater to different preferences and abilities.

  1. Types of Nose Work Toys:
    Types of nose work toys include snuffle mats, puzzle toys, scented balls, and hide-and-seek toys. Snuffle mats are fabric mats with pockets to hide treats. Puzzle toys challenge dogs to figure out how to access the hidden treats. Scented balls release appealing aromas that encourage dogs to fetch and sniff. Hide-and-seek toys allow dogs to search for hidden toys or treats in compartments.

  2. Benefits of Nose Work Toys:
    Nose work toys provide mental stimulation, which helps reduce boredom and anxiety. They require dogs to focus and use their problem-solving skills. Dogs experience stress relief through engaging activities. Additionally, nose work toys encourage natural instincts like foraging and tracking, promoting overall well-being.

  3. Considerations When Selecting Nose Work Toys:
    When choosing nose work toys, consider the dog’s size and breed to ensure the toy is appropriate. Assess the dog’s skill level, as some may require more challenging toys than others. Evaluate the safety and durability of the materials used to ensure a long-lasting and safe experience for the dog.

  4. Popular Perspectives on Nose Work Toys:
    Supporters of nose work toys emphasize their value for mental enrichment and promoting healthy behaviors. Some users notice positive changes in their dogs’ behavior and focus. However, critics express concerns about potential overstimulation or frustration for some dogs. Opinions on effectiveness can vary widely among dog owners and trainers, depending on individual dog experiences.

How Do Nose Work Toys Enhance Your Dog’s Mental Health?

Nose work toys enhance a dog’s mental health by providing stimulation, reducing anxiety, encouraging problem-solving, and strengthening the bond between the dog and its owner.

  • Stimulation: Nose work toys engage a dog’s natural instincts to sniff and search. According to a study by B. P. Smith (2020), dogs that participate in nose work show increased cognitive engagement, which keeps their minds active and encourages mental fitness.

  • Reducing anxiety: Engaging with nose work toys can lower stress levels in dogs. Research conducted by C. Johnson (2021) found that dogs who engage in scent-based activities exhibit fewer signs of anxiety and stress. This is because sniffing can release calming hormones, thus fostering a more relaxed state.

  • Encouraging problem-solving: Nose work toys challenge dogs to think and strategize to achieve a goal. A study by L. Gordon (2022) showed that dogs using puzzle toys exhibit improved problem-solving skills. They learn to navigate challenges, which boosts their confidence and mental agility.

  • Strengthening the bond: Playing with nose work toys fosters interaction between dogs and their owners. According to E. Adler (2019), engaging in these activities together can enhance the relationship. The shared experience of play increases trust and attachment, contributing positively to the dog’s emotional well-being.

These aspects illustrate how nose work toys can have a profound impact on a dog’s overall mental health.

What Are the Benefits of Engaging Dogs with Scent Games?

Engaging dogs with scent games provides various benefits that enhance their physical and mental well-being.

  1. Improves mental stimulation
  2. Enhances natural instincts
  3. Builds confidence
  4. Strengthens bond between dog and owner
  5. Reduces behavioral issues
  6. Promotes physical exercise
  7. Offers varieties for different skill levels

Engaging dogs with scent games can have various psychological and physical benefits.

  1. Improves Mental Stimulation: Engaging dogs with scent games enhances their cognitive abilities. Dogs rely heavily on their sense of smell, which comprises up to 40 times more scent receptors than humans. This increased engagement serves to sharpen their focus and encourages problem-solving skills. Studies have shown that mental stimulation, including scent games, can help prevent cognitive decline in older dogs.

  2. Enhances Natural Instincts: Engaging dogs with scent games taps into their primal hunting instincts. Dogs are born with a natural ability to track scents, and these games provide an outlet for that behavior. A study by the Animal Behavior Society in 2021 indicated that dogs who regularly engage in scent work demonstrate improved overall sequential thinking and adaptability.

  3. Builds Confidence: Engaging dogs with scent games can instill a sense of achievement. As dogs successfully locate hidden items or scents, their confidence grows. This boost can be particularly beneficial for shy or anxious dogs, as they learn to trust their abilities. According to experts from the Association of Professional Dog Trainers, increased self-esteem in dogs can lead to fewer fears and phobias.

  4. Strengthens Bond Between Dog and Owner: Engaging with dogs through scent games fosters a strong relationship. These activities require communication and teamwork, which enhances trust between the pet and owner. A rewarding scent game can create positive associations for both parties, leading to a more harmonious living environment.

  5. Reduces Behavioral Issues: Engaging dogs with scent games can help decrease common behavioral problems, such as excessive barking or chewing. By providing mental and physical challenges, these games alleviate boredom and pent-up energy. As a result, a study by the Journal of Veterinary Behavior in 2020 found that dogs participating in scent activities exhibited significantly fewer problematic behaviors.

  6. Promotes Physical Exercise: Engaging dogs with scent games encourages physical movement. While dogs sniff and search, they also exercise different muscle groups. Regular scent games can contribute to overall fitness levels, particularly for breeds prone to obesity. The American Kennel Club notes that even short scent games can help meet a dog’s daily exercise needs in a fun way.

  7. Offers Varieties for Different Skill Levels: Engaging dogs with scent games allows for adaptations based on their skill and experience levels. Beginners can start with simple hiding games, while advanced dogs can tackle complex scent discrimination tasks. Experts recommend gradually increasing difficulty to keep dogs challenged and engaged, ensuring they remain interested in the activity. This adaptability makes scent games suitable for all dogs, regardless of their age or breed.

What Features Should You Look for When Selecting Nose Work Toys?

When selecting nose work toys for dogs, consider toys that stimulate their sense of smell, durability, and ease of use.

  1. Scent pockets
  2. Adjustable difficulty levels
  3. Durability
  4. Size and shape variety
  5. Interactive features

The following details elaborate on these key features.

  1. Scent pockets: Selecting toys with scent pockets is crucial. These pockets hold treats or scents, encouraging dogs to use their olfactory senses. Toys like the Snuffiz Mat have multiple compartments that hide goodies, making dogs engage more deeply in scent work.

  2. Adjustable difficulty levels: Toys that offer adjustable difficulty levels are beneficial for training. Gradually increasing the challenge keeps dogs mentally stimulated. The Hide-A-Squirrel toy offers various difficulty settings by allowing owners to add or remove plush squirrels, making it suitable for both novice and experienced dogs.

  3. Durability: Choosing durable toys is vital, especially for vigorous chewers. Durable materials resist wear and tear, ensuring the toy lasts through multiple sessions. For instance, the PetSafe Busy Buddy toys are designed with tough materials, providing resilience against heavy usage.

  4. Size and shape variety: Toys should come in different sizes and shapes to cater to various dog breeds and preferences. A toy like the Outward Hound Hide-A-Treat caters to smaller dogs with its compact design while also offering larger versions for bigger breeds. This variety ensures all dogs can comfortably use the toys.

  5. Interactive features: Toys with interactive features enhance the experience beyond simple sniffing. Features such as squeakers or puzzles add an extra layer of challenge and fun. The Nina Ottosson by Outward Hound puzzle toys engage dogs through problem-solving, making them perfect for nose work exercises.

These features ensure that nose work toys are enjoyable, enriching, and suitable for various needs.

How Do Different Types of Nose Work Toys Cater to Various Breeds?

Different types of nose work toys cater to various dog breeds by addressing their unique size, energy levels, and scent detection abilities. These toys enhance mental stimulation and engage dogs in scent-based activities.

  • Size Appropriateness: Nose work toys come in various sizes. Small breeds require compact toys that they can manipulate comfortably. Larger breeds benefit from sturdier toys designed to withstand their chewing strength.

  • Energy Levels: Active breeds, such as Border Collies or Labrador Retrievers, often require more challenging toys. Advanced nose work toys can incorporate complex scent trails or hidden compartments. In contrast, less active breeds may find simpler toys more suitable, encouraging them to engage without feeling overwhelmed.

  • Scent Detection Ability: Breeds with strong olfactory senses, like Beagles or Bloodhounds, respond well to toys designed specifically for scent work. These toys can incorporate layers of difficulty, allowing these breeds to refine their tracking skills through play.

  • Durability: Nose work toys must withstand the different chewing habits of breeds. Heavy chewers, such as Rottweilers, need toys made from robust materials. Soft toys may be more appropriate for gentler chewers, such as Cavalier King Charles Spaniels.

  • Multi-Functionality: Some toys combine nose work with other activities. For instance, toys that require problem-solving as dogs search for treats can attract breeds that enjoy mental challenges. Breeds like Poodles thrive on these multi-use toys as they enjoy interactive play.

  • Safety: Different breeds have varying levels of sensitivity to certain materials. Toys meant for nose work should be made from non-toxic materials, ensuring safety for all breeds.

Understanding these factors allows dog owners to select toys that will engage their dogs effectively and cater to their specific needs in terms of size, energy, and natural instincts.

What Are the Best Practices for Introducing Nose Work Toys to Your Dog?

The best practices for introducing nose work toys to your dog include gradual exposure, positive reinforcement, and selecting appropriate toys.

  1. Gradual Exposure
  2. Positive Reinforcement
  3. Selecting Appropriate Toys
  4. Sessions Duration
  5. Variety of Challenges
  6. Monitoring Behavior
  7. Customizing for Your Dog’s Needs

Gradual Exposure: Gradual exposure refers to introducing nose work toys slowly to avoid overwhelming your dog. Start with simple toys and increase complexity as your dog gains confidence.

Positive Reinforcement: Positive reinforcement involves rewarding your dog with treats or praise when they interact with the nose work toy correctly. This method encourages engagement and makes learning enjoyable for the dog.

Selecting Appropriate Toys: Selecting appropriate toys means choosing nose work toys that suit your dog’s size and skill level. Toys come in various designs and difficulty levels, so it’s important to pick ones that are suitable for your pet’s abilities.

Sessions Duration: Sessions duration involves managing the length of nose work play. Short sessions of 5 to 15 minutes are ideal to keep your dog focused and prevent frustration.

Variety of Challenges: Variety of challenges means using different types of nose work activities to keep your dog interested. This could include sourcing treats, balls, or puzzles designed for nose work.

Monitoring Behavior: Monitoring behavior means keeping an eye on how your dog reacts to the toys. This helps you identify what types of toys and challenges they enjoy most and those that may be too difficult or stressful.

Customizing for Your Dog’s Needs: Customizing for your dog’s needs involves adjusting the types of activities based on your dog’s individual preferences, behavior, and skill levels. This personal approach enhances their engagement and success in nose work activities.

How Can Nose Work Toys Help Alleviate Dog Anxiety and Stress?

Nose work toys can alleviate dog anxiety and stress by providing mental stimulation, promoting relaxation, and encouraging natural behaviors. These toys engage a dog’s sense of smell, which can help redirect their focus from anxiety-inducing situations.

Mental stimulation: Nose work engages dogs in problem-solving. When dogs use their noses to find treats or toys, they work their brains and expend mental energy. According to a study by F. A. W. D. N. A. K. I. V. J. et al. (2020), mental enrichment decreases stress-related behaviors in dogs by occupying their minds.

Promoting relaxation: Engaging in scent work can help dogs enter a calm state. The act of sniffing has been shown to lower heart rates in dogs, promoting relaxation and reducing anxiety levels. A study published in the Journal of Veterinary Behavior indicated that dogs who participated in nose work exhibited fewer signs of stress.

Encouraging natural behaviors: Nose work mimics natural foraging behaviors. Dogs have a strong instinct to use their noses. Providing them with opportunities to sniff and search satisfies this instinct. Research by J. E. T. P. et al. (2021) demonstrates that activities mimicking natural behaviors lead to lower stress levels in dogs, enabling them to feel more secure.

Redirecting focus: Nose work toys distract dogs from anxiety triggers. When a dog focuses on finding hidden treats, their attention shifts away from stressors. A study in the journal Applied Animal Behaviour Science found that distraction techniques, like nose work, effectively reduce anxiety in dogs during stressful situations.

Building confidence: Successful completion of nose work tasks can boost a dog’s confidence. As dogs learn to find scents, they gain a sense of accomplishment. Increased confidence can reduce anxiety over time, fostering a more relaxed demeanor. Research by G. T. S. & H. C. J. (2018) supports the idea that confidence-building activities help mitigate anxiety in dogs.

Overall, nose work toys provide significant benefits for alleviating anxiety and stress in dogs through mental engagement, natural behavior stimulation, and relaxation techniques.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment