best water dish for dog crate

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Unlike other water dishes that tip easily or are tough to clean, the MidWest Homes for Pets Snap’y Fit Stainless Steel Food or really stood out after hands-on testing. Its secure mounting bracket and patented Snap’y Fit system keep the bowl steady and spill-proof, even when your dog nudges or pushes during mealtime. The stainless steel design resists rust and stains, making cleanup a breeze—dishwasher safe and built for daily use.

This bowl also elevates feeding at a comfortable height, which helps reduce strain on your pup’s neck and supports better digestion. The locking mechanism is strong but simple to remove for refills or cleaning. Having tested similar options, I found that many struggle with stability or rust over time. This model delivers durability, stability, and hygiene—all in one package—making it a smart choice for anyone wanting a reliable water dish for their dog crate.

Top Recommendation: MidWest Homes for Pets Snap’y Fit Stainless Steel Food or

Why We Recommend It: This product excels with its secure, easy-to-release mounting bracket, preventing spills and tip-overs. Its rust-resistant stainless steel bowl is dishwasher safe and durable for long-term use, outperforming plastic or weaker metal alternatives. The elevated design promotes comfort and digestive health, a feature that enhances both convenience and your pet’s well-being. After thorough comparison, this bowl’s superior stability, ease of cleaning, and long-lasting materials make it the best overall choice.

Best water dish for dog crate: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewMidWest Homes for Pets Snap'y Fit Stainless Steel Food orMechpia 2-Piece Stainless Steel Dog & Pet Food Water Bowlskathson Crate Dog Bowl, Removable Stainless Steel Hanging
TitleMidWest Homes for Pets Snap’y Fit Stainless Steel Food orMechpia 2-Piece Stainless Steel Dog & Pet Food Water Bowlskathson Crate Dog Bowl, Removable Stainless Steel Hanging
MaterialStainless steel with e-coated bracketStainless steel with plastic lockStainless steel with plastic outer shell
Capacity10 oz150 g
Size (Diameter)4.92 inches5.1 inches
Height2.16 inches2.1 inches
Removable/Detachable
Mounting MethodSecure mounting bracket with locking systemTurn nut clockwise to attach, counterclockwise to removeUnscrew plastic lock counterclockwise and hang
Suitable ForDogs, cats, rabbits, ferrets, squirrels, birdsSmall dogs, cats, rabbits, ferrets, squirrels, birdsSmall dogs, cats, rabbits
Dishwasher Safe
Available

MidWest Homes for Pets Snap’y Fit Stainless Steel Food or

MidWest Homes for Pets Snap
Pros:
  • Secure mounting system
  • Rust-resistant stainless steel
  • Easy to clean
Cons:
  • Slightly smaller capacity
  • Snap mechanism can be tight
Specification:
Material Stainless steel
Capacity 10 oz (fluid or food)
Mounting System Snap’y Fit locking bracket
Corrosion Resistance E-coated stainless steel
Design Features Removable and dishwasher safe bowl
Intended Use Elevated feeding for dog crates

As soon as I unboxed the MidWest Homes for Pets Snap’y Fit Stainless Steel Food or Water Dish, I noticed how solid and sleek it feels in my hand. The stainless steel bowl has a smooth, brushed finish that’s almost cool to the touch.

It’s lightweight but sturdy, giving off a sense of durability right away.

The bowl itself is a perfect size—10 oz capacity feels just right for quick meals or water refills without taking up too much space. Attaching it to the crate was a breeze thanks to the secure mounting bracket.

It snaps onto the bars firmly, yet I found it easy to remove when needed, thanks to the patented Snap’y Fit system.

The design feels thoughtful—no more worries about tipping or spilling during mealtime. The lock mechanism holds tight, but it’s simple enough to release when you want to refill or clean.

The stainless steel material is rust-resistant, so I don’t have to worry about corrosion even with daily use.

Cleaning is straightforward—just pop it in the dishwasher, and it’s good as new. I also appreciate the elevated position, which makes my dog more comfortable while eating.

The overall build feels durable and designed for long-term use, making it a practical choice for busy pet owners.

Overall, this dish combines functionality with thoughtful design, making feeding time less messy and more convenient. It looks good in the crate and holds up well over time, which is exactly what I need for daily use.

Mechpia 2-Piece Stainless Steel Dog & Pet Food Water Bowls

Mechpia 2-Piece Stainless Steel Dog & Pet Food Water Bowls
Pros:
  • Easy to detach and clean
  • Secure mounting on crate
  • Versatile for food and water
Cons:
  • Plastic lock feels flimsy
  • Size limited for large pets
Specification:
Material Stainless steel for the bowls, plastic for the fixed mounting component
Bowl Diameter 4.92 inches (12.5 cm)
Bowl Height 2.16 inches (5.5 cm)
Number of Pieces 2-pack
Installation Method Removable via clockwise/counterclockwise turning of the plastic lock
Suitable for Small dogs, cats, rabbits, ferrets, squirrels, and birds

> A common misconception is that stainless steel bowls are just basic, boring options that don’t add much to your pet’s feeding routine. After actually handling the Mechpia 2-Piece Stainless Steel Dog & Pet Food Water Bowls, I realized how wrong that idea is.

The sturdy construction feels premium in your hand, and the design is surprisingly thoughtful.

The bowls are made of durable stainless steel, which instantly reassures you about long-term use. They’re lightweight but solid, and the finish resists rust and corrosion.

What really stood out is how easy it is to detach the bowls from the plastic base. You just turn the nut clockwise, and they come right off for cleaning.

Plus, the fact that they work as both food and water bowls is a real time-saver.

Installing them on a crate is straightforward, thanks to the clever locking mechanism. Turning the plastic lock clockwise tightens the bowl securely to the cage, preventing spills or accidental knocking over.

The size, with a diameter of nearly 5 inches, is perfect for small pups, cats, or even small furry friends like rabbits or ferrets. The removable design makes refilling or cleaning a breeze, especially when you’re juggling multiple pets or busy schedules.

However, the plastic lock could feel a little flimsy if you’re dealing with very energetic pets. Also, the size might be a bit small for larger breeds or multiple animals sharing a crate.

Overall, this set of bowls offers a practical, tidy solution that keeps messes contained and your pet’s eating area neat.

<

kathson Crate Dog Bowl, Removable Stainless Steel Hanging

kathson Crate Dog Bowl, Removable Stainless Steel Hanging
Pros:
  • Easy to clean
  • Sturdy and durable
  • Promotes comfortable eating
Cons:
  • Slightly tricky setup for some enclosures
  • Not suitable for large dogs
Specification:
Material High-quality stainless steel and thickened plastic
Diameter 5.1 inches
Height 2.1 inches
Capacity 150 grams
Design Feature Removable hanging bowl for easy cleaning and adjustable installation
Intended Use Suitable for small dogs, cats, and rabbits

The kathson Crate Dog Bowl instantly caught my eye with its sleek stainless steel design and durable plastic outer shell. It feels sturdy in hand, and I appreciate the 5.1-inch diameter that fits perfectly in my small dog’s crate without taking up too much space. The kathson Crate Dog Bowl, Removable Stainless Steel Hanging is a standout choice in its category.

The removable feature makes cleaning a breeze—just unscrew the white plastic lock, take out the bowl, and rinse it under water. The 150g capacity is enough for my pup’s water needs, and the hanging design at 2.1 inches high helps keep the bowl at a comfortable height, reducing strain on his neck. When comparing different best water dish for dog crate options, this model stands out for its quality.

Installing the kathson Crate Dog Bowl was straightforward—adjust the angle, tighten the screw, and it stays securely in place. Its thickened stainless steel liner resists rust and deformation, so I know it’s built to last, even with daily use.

Overall, this two-set water and food bowl combo offers a practical, durable solution for small pets, and I’m impressed with how easy it is to keep clean and secure in the crate. It’s a simple upgrade that makes feeding time more comfortable for my dog and hassle-free for me.

Small Pet Dog Food & Water Bowls, Stainless Steel, 2 Pcs

Small Pet Dog Food & Water Bowls, Stainless Steel, 2 Pcs
Pros:
  • Anti-spill design
  • Easy to clean and dishwasher safe
  • Secure attachment to crate
Cons:
  • Suit for medium/large breeds only
  • Slightly higher price point
Specification:
Material Food-grade stainless steel
Dishwasher Safe Yes, removable for easy cleaning
Size Includes two bowls: one smaller for food, one larger for water
Mounting Compatibility Suitable for medium and large-breed dog crates, cages, or kennels
Anti-spill Design Secure attachment to prevent tipping and spillage
Durability Rust-resistant and odor-free

The moment I snapped these stainless steel bowls onto my dog’s crate, I knew I was onto something good. The anti-spill design really stands out—no more puddles of water or food messes on the floor, which is a huge relief.

The bowls attach securely and don’t wobble, even when my dog gets a little enthusiastic. The raised design keeps everything off the floor, giving my pup more space to stretch out without knocking over his food or water.

Plus, the stainless steel feels sturdy and high-quality, not flimsy or thin like some other options I’ve tried.

Cleaning is a breeze because the bowls are removable and dishwasher safe. No lingering odors or rust, which is a win for me.

I also like that the set includes two bowls—one for food, one for water—so I don’t have to juggle multiple dishes.

Installation is straightforward; I just slide the mounts onto the crate and tighten. They hold firmly without any wobbling or slipping, even when my dog nudges them.

The compact setup helps keep the crate neat and maximizes space for his bed and litter box.

Overall, these bowls are a practical upgrade from standard ones. They stay put, are easy to clean, and help keep my dog’s area tidy.

If you’re tired of spills and messes, these could be exactly what you need.

PETMAKER Stainless Steel Dog Bowls, 8oz, Set of 2

PETMAKER Stainless Steel Dog Bowls, 8oz, Set of 2
Pros:
  • Durable stainless steel
  • Easy to clean
  • Secure hanging design
Cons:
  • Slightly small capacity
  • Hooks may loosen over time
Specification:
Material Stainless Steel and Chromed Iron
Capacity 8 ounces per bowl
Dimensions 5 inches (length) x 1.5 inches (height)
Design Features Hanging with wire hook brackets, elevated for ergonomic feeding
Durability Rust-resistant, chew-proof, crack-proof
Cleaning Dishwasher safe

As I pulled these PETMAKER stainless steel bowls out of the box, I immediately noticed their sturdy build and shiny finish. The sleek design looked durable enough to withstand my dog’s enthusiastic eating habits.

When I attached them to his crate using the wire hooks, they sat securely without wobbling or slipping.

Filling each bowl with water or food, I appreciated how easy it was to remove them for cleaning. The stainless steel feels solid in hand, and I like that it’s rust-resistant.

Hanging them at a comfortable height made feeding my small dog effortless, and I could tell he appreciated the new, more natural position for eating.

Over the next few days, I used these bowls both for water and snacks. They held 8 ounces comfortably, which was enough for my pup’s needs without being bulky.

They stayed in place during his rambunctious moments, and I didn’t worry about him chewing or breaking them, thanks to the durable material.

The dishwasher-safe feature made cleanup quick, especially after a messy meal. I also liked that I could easily detach the bowls from the hooks, making maintenance a breeze.

Overall, these bowls proved to be a reliable, practical addition to crate feeding, blending convenience with durability.

What Should You Look for When Choosing the Best Water Dish for a Dog Crate?

When choosing the best water dish for a dog crate, consider the following factors:

  • Size: The water dish should be appropriately sized for your dog’s breed and crate space.
  • Material: The material of the water dish can affect its durability and ease of cleaning.
  • Stability: A stable design is crucial to prevent spills and messes within the crate.
  • Attachment options: Some water dishes feature attachment mechanisms to secure them to the crate.
  • Ease of cleaning: A water dish that is easy to remove and clean will help maintain hygiene.
  • Portability: If you travel with your dog, a lightweight and portable water dish is preferable.

The size of the water dish is essential as it must accommodate the amount of water your dog needs without taking up too much space in the crate. A dish that is too large may lead to spills, while one that is too small may not provide enough hydration.

The material of the water dish can vary, with options like stainless steel, plastic, or ceramic. Stainless steel is often preferred for its durability and resistance to bacteria, while plastic may be lighter but can wear out or absorb odors over time.

Stability is critical in a water dish to prevent it from tipping over, which can create a mess and deprive your dog of water. Look for designs that have a wider base or non-slip features to keep the dish secure during movement.

Attachment options can be beneficial as they help secure the water dish to the crate, minimizing the risk of spills and making it more difficult for your dog to knock it over. Some dishes come with clips or brackets that attach directly to the crate walls.

Ease of cleaning is an important consideration since a dirty water dish can lead to health issues for your dog. Opt for a design that allows for simple removal and is dishwasher safe for hassle-free maintenance.

Portability is particularly important if you’re on the go. A lightweight, collapsible water dish can make it easy to provide hydration during travel or trips, ensuring your dog stays hydrated wherever you go.

Why Is Material Important for a Dog Crate Water Dish?

This happens because the material of a dog crate water dish significantly impacts durability, safety, and ease of cleaning, making it essential for the well-being of the pet.

According to a study published by the American Veterinary Medical Association, the choice of materials in pet products can affect not only the longevity of the item but also the health of the animal using it. For instance, stainless steel is often recommended due to its resistance to bacteria and ease of sanitization, while plastic dishes can leach harmful chemicals over time, particularly if they are not BPA-free.

The underlying mechanism involves the interaction between the material and the dog’s behavior. Dogs are known to chew and play with their water dishes, and materials like metal or heavy-duty ceramic are less likely to be damaged compared to plastic. Furthermore, a stable water dish reduces the risk of spills, which can lead to a messy crate environment and potential stress for the dog. This physical stability is crucial as it helps maintain hydration levels, which are vital for a dog’s health, especially when left in a crate for extended periods.

Moreover, the weight and design of the dish can also play a role in preventing tipping, which is a common issue with lighter, less stable materials. A dish that remains upright ensures that the dog has continuous access to fresh water, thereby promoting healthy drinking habits and preventing dehydration. This relationship between material choice, dish stability, and hydration underscores the importance of selecting the best water dish for a dog crate.

How Does Size Influence the Effectiveness of a Dog Water Dish?

A water dish that is lightweight and compact is easier to use in crates, especially when traveling or moving the crate around. This portability allows for convenience without compromising on your dog’s access to water.

A larger or heavier base can prevent spills, making it more efficient for use in a confined space like a crate. This stability is especially important for active dogs who may move around a lot, helping to keep their crate clean and dry.

Which Design Features Help Prevent Spills in Dog Crate Water Dishes?

Several design features can effectively help prevent spills in dog crate water dishes:

  • No-Spill Design: These dishes often have a unique shape or mechanism that minimizes the risk of water spilling out, even if the dog moves around in the crate.
  • Weighted Base: A heavier base can help keep the dish stable, reducing the chances of it being tipped over by an active dog.
  • Non-Slip Bottom: Dishes with a rubberized or textured bottom prevent sliding on the crate floor, ensuring the dish remains in place during use.
  • Gravity Feeders: These dishes provide a continuous supply of water without the need for frequent refills, and their design often ensures water only comes out when the dog drinks, minimizing spills.
  • Enclosed or Hooded Design: Some dishes feature a cover or hood that protects the water from being splashed out or knocked over, while allowing the dog access to drink comfortably.

No-Spill Design: These water dishes are engineered with special contours or barriers that help contain the liquid within the dish, even as dogs jostle or bump it. They can be particularly useful for excited or playful dogs who might otherwise create a mess during their crate time.

Weighted Base: The weight of the base provides stability, making it difficult for a dog to tip the dish over while trying to drink. This feature is especially beneficial for larger breeds or those that are more energetic, as it helps to keep the dish upright regardless of the dog’s movements.

Non-Slip Bottom: A non-slip bottom is crucial for maintaining the position of the water dish, as it grips the surface of the crate floor. This feature can prevent sliding and help ensure that the dish remains in the same spot, reducing the likelihood of spills.

Gravity Feeders: These dishes allow for a steady flow of water from a reservoir, so dogs have access to fresh water without the need for constant refilling. Their design often minimizes spills, as they release water only when the dog drinks, preventing overflows.

Enclosed or Hooded Design: Dishes with an enclosure or hood limit the amount of water that can escape, even if the dog nudges or bumps into it. This design not only helps prevent spills but also keeps the water cleaner by shielding it from debris that might fall into the crate.

What Are the Most Common Types of Water Dishes for Dog Crates?

The most common types of water dishes for dog crates include:

  • Heavy-Duty Stainless Steel Bowls: These bowls are durable and resistant to tipping, making them ideal for crate use.
  • Non-Slip Plastic Bowls: Designed with a rubber base, these bowls prevent sliding and spilling, providing a stable water source for dogs.
  • Hanging Water Bowls: These bowls attach to the side of the crate, ensuring that water is always within reach without taking up floor space.
  • Travel Water Bottles: These are convenient for on-the-go hydration and can be used in crates for dogs who drink less frequently.
  • Automatic Waterers: These devices refill automatically, ensuring a constant water supply, which can be beneficial for dogs that drink a lot.

Heavy-duty stainless steel bowls are favored for their durability and resistance to rust and corrosion, making them long-lasting options for dogs that may chew or tip over their dishes. They are easy to clean and do not retain odors, which is important for maintaining a healthy environment in the crate.

Non-slip plastic bowls feature a rubber base that grips the floor of the crate, preventing accidental spills and ensuring that water remains accessible to your pet. They are often lightweight and easy to transport, but it’s essential to choose a high-quality plastic that won’t break easily.

Hanging water bowls are particularly useful in smaller crates, as they save space on the floor. They attach securely to the crate’s bars, allowing dogs to drink without the risk of knocking over their bowl, and are typically easy to refill.

Travel water bottles are designed for convenience and can be filled and used in crates during car trips or outings. They feature a design that allows for controlled water dispensing, which helps to prevent spills and waste.

Automatic waterers are a great option for dogs that drink frequently, as they maintain a constant water supply. These systems can be connected to a water source and are especially useful for long periods when the dog is in the crate, ensuring they always have access to fresh water.

What Benefits Do Spill-Proof Water Dishes Offer?

Easy to Clean: Many spill-proof water dishes are specifically designed for easy cleaning, allowing pet owners to quickly remove any residue or dirt. This convenience contributes to better hygiene and helps maintain a healthy drinking environment for your dog.

Stability: Spill-proof dishes often have anti-tipping features, such as weighted bases or suction designs, which keep them securely in place. This stability ensures that your dog can drink without causing a mess, making these dishes particularly useful in crate settings.

Is a Bottle-Style Water Dish a Better Choice for Crates?

A Bottle-Style Water Dish can be a practical choice for dog crates due to its design and functionality.

  • Leak-Proof Design: Bottle-style water dishes are typically designed to prevent leaks, which helps keep the crate clean and dry. This feature is particularly beneficial for dogs that may knock over traditional bowls, as it minimizes mess and ensures that your dog always has access to fresh water.
  • Space Efficient: These water dishes often take up less space compared to traditional bowls, making them ideal for the confined space of a crate. Their vertical design allows them to be mounted on the side of the crate, which can free up floor space for your dog to move around comfortably.
  • Consistent Water Supply: A bottle-style dish provides a continuous supply of water as it uses gravity to refill the bowl when the level gets low. This is particularly useful during long periods when the dog is left alone, ensuring that they stay hydrated without the need for frequent refills.
  • Easy to Clean: Many bottle-style water dishes are made of materials that can be easily detached and cleaned. Regular maintenance is essential for your dog’s health, and a simple design can make it much easier to ensure that the water remains fresh and clean.
  • Durability: Typically made from sturdy materials like plastic or stainless steel, bottle-style dishes are designed to withstand the wear and tear of daily use. This durability means that they are less likely to crack or break compared to traditional ceramic or glass bowls, making them a long-lasting investment.

How Do Different Water Dishes Support Your Dog’s Hydration Needs?

Choosing the right water dish for your dog’s crate is essential for ensuring proper hydration while being confined.

  • Stainless Steel Bowls: These are durable and resistant to rust and corrosion, making them ideal for long-term use. They are also easy to clean and less likely to harbor bacteria compared to plastic options.
  • Non-Slip Water Dishes: These dishes come with a rubber base to prevent sliding and spilling, ensuring that your dog has access to water without creating a mess in the crate. They are particularly useful for enthusiastic drinkers or active dogs.
  • Gravity-Fed Waterers: These systems automatically refill the water bowl as it is consumed, ensuring that your dog always has access to fresh water. This can be particularly beneficial for long periods in a crate, reducing the need for frequent refills.
  • Hanging Water Bowls: Designed to attach to the crate’s bars, these bowls save space and prevent tipping or spillage. They are also convenient for smaller crates where floor space is limited.
  • Travel Water Dishes: These portable options are typically collapsible and lightweight, making them ideal for on-the-go hydration. They can be used not only in crates but also during trips, hikes, or visits to the park.
  • Self-Watering Systems: Advanced options that utilize a reservoir and a valve to dispense water as needed, ensuring a continuous supply. These are great for dogs that might be in their crate for extended periods and can help reduce the frequency of refilling.

Why Is Constant Access to Fresh Water Crucial for Dogs?

Constant access to fresh water is crucial for dogs because it ensures their hydration, supports vital bodily functions, and helps prevent health issues such as urinary tract infections and kidney disease.

According to the American Kennel Club (AKC), dogs can suffer from dehydration quickly, especially in warm weather or after physical exertion, which can lead to serious health complications. A study published in the Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine highlights that dogs require an adequate intake of water to maintain normal body temperature and facilitate digestion, nutrient absorption, and waste elimination.

The underlying mechanism involves the role of water in physiological processes. Water is essential for maintaining blood volume and regulating temperature through sweating and panting. When a dog is dehydrated, these processes become less efficient, leading to increased heart rate and potential organ dysfunction. Furthermore, without sufficient water intake, dogs may develop concentrated urine, which increases the risk of urinary tract problems and kidney stones, emphasizing the importance of providing a reliable source of fresh water, especially in confined spaces like a dog crate.

Which Are the Top Recommended Water Dishes for Dog Crates?

The top recommended water dishes for dog crates include options that prioritize safety, convenience, and spill resistance.

  • Non-Tip Water Bowl: These bowls often have a weighted bottom or a design that prevents tipping, making them ideal for energetic dogs.
  • Hanging Water Dispenser: This option attaches to the side of the crate, allowing for easy access to water without taking up floor space.
  • Travel Water Bottle: Designed for portability, these bottles can be attached to the crate and provide a quick, spill-free way to hydrate your dog.
  • Stainless Steel Bowl: Durable and easy to clean, stainless steel bowls are resistant to chewing and do not retain odors, making them a hygienic choice.
  • Slow Feed Water Bowl: These bowls are designed to minimize splashing and allow dogs to drink at a slower pace, which can be beneficial for dogs prone to gulping water.

The non-tip water bowl is great for active dogs that may knock over standard bowls, as its design helps keep the water in place, ensuring your pet stays hydrated without creating a mess.

A hanging water dispenser is an excellent choice for crate setups, as it keeps the water off the ground and reduces the risk of spills while still providing easy access for your dog.

Travel water bottles are perfect for those who frequently move their dogs in and out of crates, allowing you to provide fresh water without needing a separate bowl.

Stainless steel bowls not only resist wear and tear but also have the added benefit of being dishwasher safe, making cleaning a breeze and ensuring your dog’s water stays fresh.

Slow feed water bowls are particularly useful for dogs that tend to drink too quickly, as they help prevent choking and promote a more measured drinking pace, reducing the risk of digestive issues.

What Do Customer Reviews Say About These Water Dishes?

Customer reviews highlight several popular options for the best water dish for dog crates:

  • Non-Spill Dish: Many customers praise non-spill water dishes for their effectiveness in keeping the crate clean. These dishes often feature a design that minimizes the risk of spilling, allowing dogs to drink without creating a mess in their living space.
  • Collapsible Water Bowls: Reviews frequently mention collapsible water bowls as a convenient option for dog crates. They are lightweight and portable, making them ideal for travel while also providing a sufficient water supply for dogs in their crates.
  • Stainless Steel Bowls: Customers appreciate stainless steel bowls for their durability and easy cleaning. Unlike plastic, they do not absorb odors or stains, ensuring that the water remains fresh and the bowl lasts longer.
  • Heavy-Duty Ceramic Bowls: Some reviews recommend heavy-duty ceramic bowls for their stability and aesthetic appeal. These bowls are often weighted, which helps prevent tipping, and they come in various designs that can complement home decor.
  • Automatic Water Dispenser: Many dog owners have found automatic water dispensers to be a game-changer for crate use. These devices ensure a constant supply of fresh water, reducing the need for frequent refills and allowing dogs to hydrate at their leisure.
Related Post:

Leave a Comment