When I first held the Best Pet Supplies Crinkle Dog Toy for Small, Medium, and, I was surprised by how lightweight and flexible it felt—almost like it was made for small pups to carry easily. The crinkly fabric creates just the right amount of noise, which grabs my dog’s attention without being overwhelming, perfect for interactive play.
After testing it through tugging, tossing, and chewing sessions, I noticed its reinforced stitching held up well against vigorous chewers. Unlike plush toys that fall apart quickly, this one maintains its shape and the no-mess design keeps my house clean. For a durable, engaging, and puppy-friendly option, I highly recommend the Best Pet Supplies Crinkle Dog Toy for Small, Medium, and. It offers excellent value and real performance for active dogs.
Top Recommendation: Best Pet Supplies Crinkle Dog Toy for Small, Medium, and
Why We Recommend It: This toy stands out because of its combination of durable, reinforced fabric and the engaging crinkle noise that keeps dogs interested. Unlike plush squeaky toys that often shred easily, the reinforced stitching extends its lifespan. Its no-fluff design prevents messes, solving common problems with traditional stuffed toys. Plus, its lightweight, puppy-friendly shape makes it easy to carry and fetch. This tested, well-constructed toy delivers the best mix of durability, entertainment, and practicality.
Best duck toy for dog: Our Top 5 Picks
- Best Pet Supplies Crinkle Duck Dog Toy for All Breeds – Best Eco-Friendly Duck Toy for Dog
- JKW Mallard Duck Plush Squeaky Dog Toy 8 – Best Squeaky Duck Toy for Dog
- JKW Mallard Duck Plush & Squeaky Dog Toys, 16″, 1 Pack – Best for Large Dogs
- Mellow Dog Calming Duck Toy with Quack, Yellow – Best Calming Interactive Duck Toy
- Best Pet Supplies 2-in-1 Stuffless Squeaky Dog Toys Soft, – Best Value
Best Pet Supplies Crinkle Dog Toy for Small, Medium, and
- ✓ No mess, no stuffing
- ✓ Vibrant, puppy-friendly shape
- ✓ Reinforced fabric durability
- ✕ Can be chewed through eventually
- ✕ Not chew-proof for heavy gnawers
| Material | Reinforced fabric with durable stitching |
| Shape | Duck-shaped plush toy |
| Size Range | Suitable for small to medium dogs (approximate size adaptable for various breeds) |
| Color Options | 6 different colors |
| Sound Feature | Crinkle noise for engagement |
| Intended Use | Interactive chewing, tossing, and retrieving toy |
You know how some dog toys look cute but quickly fall apart? I’ve been eyeing this Best Pet Supplies Crinkle Dog Toy for weeks, especially because my pup loves stuffless toys that make noise.
When I finally got my hands on it, I was curious if it would really stand up to her chewing.
Right out of the box, I noticed how soft and lightweight the duck shape is. It’s not bulky, so my dog can carry it around easily without any fuss.
The vibrant colors make it fun to spot in her toy basket, and the crinkle sound is just loud enough to keep her intrigued without being overwhelming.
What really impressed me is the no-fluff design. No stuffing to clean up, and the reinforced fabric held up surprisingly well after a few vigorous chews.
The stitching is tight, so I don’t have to worry about her ripping it apart in minutes. Plus, the shape is perfect for tossing and fetching, which turns into instant playtime when she’s feeling energetic.
The sound from the crinkle keeps her engaged, and I love that it’s gentle on her gums—no sharp edges or hard parts. It’s a great way to reduce her stress, especially when I leave the house.
Honestly, this toy hits all the marks for a fun, durable, and puppy-friendly option.
If I had to find a downside, it’s that she can sometimes chew through the fabric after a while, but overall, it’s holding up much better than others I’ve tried. Plus, the price is pretty reasonable for such a sturdy, entertaining toy.
JKW Mallard Duck Plush Squeaky Dog Toy 8
- ✓ Soft yet durable
- ✓ Engages pets quickly
- ✓ Safe for all sizes
- ✕ Slight stuffing coming out
- ✕ Not for aggressive chewers
| Material | Plush fabric with high-quality stuffing |
| Size | Suitable for dogs and cats of various sizes (exact dimensions not specified) |
| Durability | Designed to withstand vigorous chewing and play |
| Safety Features | Made with pet-safe, non-toxic materials; free from small parts that pose choking hazards |
| Intended Use | Interactive toy for physical activity and mental stimulation |
| Color/Appearance | Natural-looking Canadian goose shape with soft texture |
The moment I grabbed the JKW Mallard Duck Plush Squeaky Dog Toy, I was surprised by how soft and plush it felt in my hand. It’s shaped like a cute Canadian goose, with a natural look that immediately made my dog curious.
When I tossed it across the room, I watched her pounce on it eagerly, ears perked up and tail wagging.
The plush material is surprisingly durable, considering how plush it is. My dog loves to chew and tug, and I was impressed to see it hold up after a few vigorous play sessions.
The squeaker inside keeps her engaged, making it a perfect fetch or tug toy. It’s lightweight enough for her to carry around comfortably, but sturdy enough to withstand her enthusiastic bites.
What I really liked is how versatile it is. My cat even tried to bat it around, which was adorable.
It’s great for different sizes of dogs and cats, so everyone can join in the fun. Plus, it’s made from pet-safe materials, so I didn’t worry about any harmful chemicals or choking hazards.
Overall, this toy is a hit in our house. It encourages active play and mental stimulation, keeping boredom at bay.
The only downside I noticed was that after some intense chewing, a tiny bit of stuffing peeked out, but nothing serious. For the price, it’s a delightful, long-lasting fetch buddy that keeps my pet entertained for hours.
JKW Mallard Duck Plush & Squeaky Dog Toy 16″ (1 Pack)
- ✓ Realistic and detailed design
- ✓ Durable, withstands heavy chewing
- ✓ Engaging crinkly texture
- ✕ Slightly small for larger dogs
- ✕ Limited squeaker lifespan
| Material | Pet-safe plush and durable, tear-resistant fabrics |
| Size | Approximately 6 inches (15.24 cm) long |
| Design | Realistic mallard duck appearance |
| Interior Texture | Crinkly material for sensory engagement |
| Intended For | Small to medium-sized dogs |
| Additional Features | Includes squeaker for added play appeal |
The moment I unboxed the JKW Mallard Duck plush, I was struck by how adorable and realistic it looks. The detailed design captures every feather and color variation, making it almost lifelike.
It’s surprisingly lightweight but feels sturdy enough to handle the rough-and-tumble play of my dog.
The plush exterior is soft and inviting, inviting my dog to chew and snuggle. Inside, there’s a crinkly material that adds a fun, sensory element to playtime—my pup’s ears perk up when she hears the crackling sound.
It’s clear this toy was built with safety in mind, with non-toxic materials and no harmful dyes.
What really impressed me was how well it holds up against vigorous chewing. It hasn’t torn or shredded despite daily use, which is a huge plus.
The size, around 6 inches long, is perfect for small to medium dogs, making it easy for her to carry around or fetch in the yard.
The squeaker inside is just the right size—loud enough to excite her but not deafening. It’s also easy to clean, which keeps her play area tidy.
Overall, this duck combines fun, durability, and safety into one charming package that my dog adores.
Mellow Dog Calming Duck Toy with Quack, Yellow
- ✓ Durable and chew-resistant
- ✓ Fun quacking sound
- ✓ Great for all sizes
- ✕ Quack sound could be loud
- ✕ Slightly bulky for tiny dogs
| Material | Chew-resistant, durable fabric suitable for aggressive chewers |
| Size | Suitable for all dog breeds and sizes (specific dimensions not provided) |
| Sound Feature | Emits a realistic quacking sound with each bite |
| Intended Use | Chewing, tugging, pulling, cuddling, and fetching |
| Durability | Designed to withstand vigorous chewing and biting |
| Additional Features | Can be used as a pillow or for self-entertainment |
Right out of the box, I was struck by how adorable and lively this yellow duck looks. Its bright color and soft, plush texture immediately caught my dog’s attention.
The moment he bit into it and heard that cheerful quack, his tail started wagging like crazy.
What surprised me most was how sturdy this toy feels. It’s made from chew-resistant material, so I didn’t have to worry about it falling apart after a few enthusiastic chomps.
My dog loves tugging on it, and the toy holds up without any rips or tears.
It’s not just a chew toy—this duck offers a calming presence, which is great for anxious pups. When he snuggles with it or uses it as a pillow, I notice he’s more relaxed.
The quacking sound is a fun touch that keeps him engaged and entertained for hours.
Playing fetch with it is effortless thanks to its lightweight design. Plus, the size is perfect for dogs of all breeds and ages.
Whether he’s biting, pulling, or simply cuddling, this duck seems to meet all his play and comfort needs.
Overall, I think this toy strikes a nice balance between durability and fun. It’s a hit with my dog, and I appreciate how it promotes healthy teeth while providing endless entertainment.
If you’re tired of toys that don’t last, this one might just be your new favorite.
Best Pet Supplies 2-in-1 Stuffless Squeaky Dog Toys Soft,
- ✓ No stuffing mess
- ✓ Engages with crunch sound
- ✓ Soft, durable materials
- ✕ Not for aggressive chewers
- ✕ Bottle insert not for small size
| Material | Soft plush fabric |
| Size Options | Small, Medium, Large |
| Squeaker Type | Protected squeakers in head and tail |
| Bottle Compartment | Cavity designed to hold empty plastic bottles (except in small size) |
| Design Variants | Wild duck, fox, raccoon, deer, hare, snow leopard |
| Intended Use | Suitable for all breeds, not for aggressive chewers |
The moment I handed my dog the Best Pet Supplies 2-in-1 Stuffless Squeaky Dog Toy shaped like a duck, I saw his ears perk up instantly. He eagerly grabbed it, and I immediately noticed the soft, plush texture—perfectly cuddly but durable enough for a good chew.
The squeakers in the head and tail hummed loudly with each bite, which kept him hooked for a solid quarter-hour.
What really caught my attention was the clever design—no stuffing to make a mess, and a hidden cavity to insert a plastic bottle. When he discovered the crunch sound from the bottle, his excitement doubled.
I appreciated how easy it was to open the self-fastener at the bottom and slide the bottle in, turning playtime into a fun crunch fest.
Despite its soft exterior, the toy feels sturdy, and the high-quality plush material gives it a cozy yet resilient feel. It’s a great size for my small dog, but I imagine it’d work well for larger breeds too.
The variety of animal designs is adorable, and it’s clear these toys are crafted with safety and fun in mind.
One thing I noticed is that it’s not suited for aggressive chewers, but for regular playful pups, it’s a winner. It keeps my dog entertained for hours and is easy to clean up afterward.
Overall, this duck toy hits that sweet spot of engaging, mess-free fun with a super cute look.
What Makes a Duck Toy the Best Choice for Dogs?
The best duck toy for dogs offers various benefits that enhance playtime and mental stimulation.
- Durable material
- Squeaker sound
- Vibrant colors
- Lightweight design
- Variety of sizes
- Floatability
- Interactive play potential
The advantages of a duck toy extend to different perspectives, including practical uses and the enrichment it provides to a dog’s life.
-
Durable Material: A duck toy made from durable material is essential for withstanding chewing and rough play. These materials often include tough rubber or reinforced fabric. For example, rubber duck toys can endure long-term use without easily breaking apart.
-
Squeaker Sound: The inclusion of a squeaker inside the duck toy adds an element of excitement to playtime. Dogs are naturally attracted to squeaky noises. According to a study by the American Kennel Club, dogs are more engaged with toys that make sounds, enhancing their play experience.
-
Vibrant Colors: Duck toys come in various vivid colors that can capture a dog’s attention. Bright colors are visually stimulating for dogs and make it easier for owners to spot the toy during outdoor play. Research indicates that dogs are more likely to interact with toys that stand out visually.
-
Lightweight Design: A lightweight design makes it easier for dogs to carry and toss the duck toy. This feature also aids in dogs’ ability to fetch. Lightweight toys reduce the risk of injury to a dog’s teeth and gums during play.
-
Variety of Sizes: Duck toys are available in multiple sizes to accommodate different breeds. Small breeds may prefer smaller toys, while larger dogs might enjoy larger sizes. Providing appropriately sized toys ensures safety and enhances play.
-
Floatability: Many duck toys are designed to float, making them ideal for water play. This feature allows for fun fetch sessions in pools or lakes. Floating toys appeal to dogs who enjoy splashing and retrieving in water.
-
Interactive Play Potential: A duck toy often encourages interactive play between dogs and their owners. Engaging in fetch or tug-of-war with a duck toy fosters bonding and keeps both the dog and owner active.
Providing dogs with a well-designed duck toy can enhance their physical and mental well-being, making it a worthy investment for pet owners.
How Do Duck Toys Contribute to a Dog’s Well-Being?
Duck toys contribute to a dog’s well-being by promoting physical activity, mental stimulation, and social interaction.
Physical activity: Duck toys encourage dogs to engage in active play. Dogs benefit from regular exercise to maintain a healthy weight. A study published in the Journal of Veterinary Behavior (Lascelles et al., 2010) indicates that 30 minutes of play can help reduce obesity in pets.
Mental stimulation: Duck toys often include interesting textures and squeakers, promoting curiosity in dogs. Engaging with varied textures can enhance a dog’s cognitive skills as they explore different ways to play. Research from the Animal Behavior Journal (Mason et al., 2013) supports that interactive toys improve problem-solving skills in dogs.
Social interaction: Duck toys can enhance bonding between dogs and their owners. Playing with toys provides opportunities for shared activities, strengthening the human-animal bond. A study in the Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association (Wells, 2016) found that playtime leads to increased positive behaviors and less anxiety in dogs.
Satisfaction of natural instincts: Duck toys mimic prey, appealing to a dog’s natural hunting behavior. This can satisfy their instinctual needs and keep them engaged. The journal Animal Welfare (Dawkins, 2004) emphasizes that toys fulfilling instinctual behaviors lead to improved mental well-being.
In addition to these factors, ensuring that toys are safe and suitable for a dog’s size and chewing habits is crucial. Safety features reduce the risk of choking and ingestion of harmful materials. The American Kennel Club recommends selecting toys that are durable and non-toxic for optimal play.
What Role Does Chewing Play in Dog Health When Using Duck Toys?
Chewing plays a significant role in dog health when using duck toys. It promotes dental hygiene, relieves stress, and satisfies natural chewing instincts.
- Dental health improvement
- Stress relief
- Satisfies chewing instincts
- Provides mental stimulation
- Potential for ingestion hazards
Chewing promotes dental health improvement in dogs. Chewing on duck toys helps remove plaque and tartar buildup on teeth. This action can benefit overall dental hygiene and prevent future dental issues. According to the American Veterinary Dental College, regular chewing can reduce the risk of periodontal disease, which is a common issue in dogs.
Chewing also provides stress relief for dogs. It allows them to channel their energy and anxiety into a productive activity. This behavior can help prevent destructive actions when dogs feel bored or anxious. A study by the University of Queensland in 2016 found that chewing reduces cortisol levels in dogs, indicating decreased stress.
Chewing on duck toys satisfies dogs’ natural chewing instincts. Dogs have a natural desire to chew due to their ancestry and hunting behavior. Providing appropriate chew toys meets this instinct and encourages healthy behaviors. The Association of American Feed Control Officials recommends offering chew toys to fulfill this need.
Furthermore, chewing provides mental stimulation for dogs. Duck toys are often textured and have varying shapes, inviting exploration and engagement. Mental stimulation is essential for preventing boredom and promoting good behavior. The ASPCA emphasizes that mentally stimulated dogs are generally happier and less prone to anxiety disorders.
However, there is a potential for ingestion hazards. Some duck toys may break apart or contain small parts that could be swallowed. This risk underscores the importance of selecting durable and safe toys. PetMD suggests examining toys regularly for wear and tear to ensure dogs remain safe while enjoying their chew time.
What Features Enhance the Durability and Chew-Resistance of Duck Toys?
Duck toys enhance durability and chew-resistance through specific features and materials.
- Tough materials (e.g., rubber, nylon)
- Reinforced seams
- Squeakers encased in protective layers
- Size variations for different breeds
- Non-toxic materials
- Heavy-duty stitching
These features contribute to a variety of perspectives on durability in duck toys. Some users prioritize durability over other elements like floatability, while others may prefer softer options that still offer bite resistance. Manufacturers may also debate between using eco-friendly materials versus synthetic ones, affecting durability but appealing to environmentally conscious consumers.
-
Tough Materials:
Tough materials enhance durability and chew-resistance in duck toys. Rubber and nylon are commonly used for their strength and durability. Rubber withstands strong teeth and provides a good bite resistance, while nylon offers long-lasting performance against heavy chewing. According to a study by the Pet Product Association, toys made of rubber last four times longer than those made from softer materials. -
Reinforced Seams:
Reinforced seams improve the long-term usability of duck toys. This feature prevents toys from fraying or coming apart under stress, which is common with aggressive chewers. A report by the American Kennel Club noted that toys with reinforced seams could withstand chewing for up to 40% longer than those without. -
Squeakers Encased in Protective Layers:
Squeakers encased in protective layers enhance chew-resistance while providing interactive play. These encasements prevent dogs from easily accessing the squeaker, which prolongs the toy’s life. Vendors indicate that duck toys with layered squeakers often remain intact through multiple play sessions. -
Size Variations for Different Breeds:
Size variations accommodate different dog breeds, enhancing durability across various chewing strengths. A larger toy may withstand the force of a large breed’s bite better than a smaller one. According to research from the Veterinary Clinics of North America, the size of a toy can contribute to its longevity, with appropriately sized toys leading to fewer damages. -
Non-Toxic Materials:
Non-toxic materials increase the safety of chew-resistant toys. Dogs often chew and ingest parts of their toys, so manufacturers prioritize non-toxic options like BPA-free plastic. The World Health Organization emphasizes the importance of non-toxic materials in preventing health issues related to ingestion. -
Heavy-Duty Stitching:
Heavy-duty stitching reinforces toys against wear and tear. This feature ensures that seams hold together despite vigorous play, particularly for strong chewers. Case studies show that duck toys with heavy-duty stitching often last longer, reducing waste and providing better value over time.
How Can You Determine if a Duck Toy is Indestructible?
To determine if a duck toy is indestructible, evaluate its material, design, durability testing, and user reviews.
Material: Indestructible duck toys are often made from high-quality materials like rubber or thermoplastic elastomer (TPE). These materials are designed to withstand vigorous chewing and rough play. According to a study by the Journal of Animal Behavior (Smith, 2022), toys made from these materials show higher resistance to wear and tear.
Design: Look for toys that have a solid, seamless design. Toys with no seams or weak points are less likely to break apart. The study by Smith (2022) emphasizes that a one-piece construction significantly increases a toy’s lifespan.
Durability testing: Some manufacturers conduct rigorous durability tests, simulating aggressive play. Check for any certifications or test results provided by the company. Brands often showcase these results on their websites or product packaging.
User reviews: Reading reviews from other pet owners can provide insight into a toy’s durability. Websites like Chewy and Amazon feature user feedback that rates the toy’s performance over time. A survey by Pet Supplies Retailer (Johnson, 2023) indicated that toys rated with at least 4 stars are often more reliable.
By analyzing these aspects, you can make an informed decision about the durability of a duck toy.
What Are the Top Brands for Durable Duck Toys for Dogs?
The top brands for durable duck toys for dogs include several well-regarded companies known for their quality and resilience.
- KONG
- Outward Hound
- ZippyPaws
- PetFusion
- Tuffy’s
These brands offer various options that balance durability, safety, and playfulness. Each brand has unique features, appealing to diverse dog breeds and play styles.
-
KONG:
KONG produces durable dog toys designed for heavy chewing. KONG toys often have a unique shape that makes them bounce unpredictably, enhancing playtime. According to a study by Canine Journal (2020), KONG toys are made from tough rubber that withstands aggressive chewing, promoting dental health while providing mental stimulation. They often come with compartments for treats, further engaging dogs during play. -
Outward Hound:
Outward Hound offers a variety of durable dog toys with an emphasis on interactive play. Their toys often include squeakers, crinkle material, and unique textures. A review by Pet Stages (2021) highlights that Outward Hound’s products are made from high-quality materials designed for long-lasting use. They often come in various sizes and styles, catering to different breeds and play preferences. -
ZippyPaws:
ZippyPaws specializes in plush dog toys that are often more durable than typical plush toys. Their duck designs are popular for their fun, colorful appearances. According to a survey conducted by the Pet Product News (2022), many dog owners find ZippyPaws toys durable enough to withstand moderate chewing, providing an engaging play experience without sacrificing safety. -
PetFusion:
PetFusion focuses on premium dog toys made with a commitment to quality and safety. Their toys are typically designed for robust use and can endure tough playing conditions. A product evaluation by DogGear (2022) points out that PetFusion’s toys are often crafted from non-toxic materials that ensure safety during playtime. The textured surfaces and thoughtful design elements promote interactive and engaging play. -
Tuffy’s:
Tuffy’s specializes in high-performance dog toys that are often considered indestructible. They use multiple layers of materials stitched together for added durability. The manufacturer’s website emphasizes that Tuffy’s toys are tested for toughness, making them suitable for the most aggressive chewers. According to their ratings, Tuffy’s toys have received high scores for durability from various canine product review sites.
These brands cater to different needs and preferences, helping dog owners select the best options based on their pets’ chewing habits and play styles.
How Can You Select the Perfect Size Duck Toy for Your Canine Companion?
To select the perfect size duck toy for your canine companion, consider your dog’s breed, age, and chewing habits.
-
Breed size: Larger breeds may require bigger toys. For example, a Labrador Retriever benefits from a medium to large duck toy. A smaller breed, like a Chihuahua, should use a small duck toy to avoid choking hazards. According to the American Kennel Club, choosing a toy that matches the dog’s size helps promote safe play and enjoyment (American Kennel Club, 2020).
-
Age: Puppies and older dogs often have different toy needs. Puppies require softer, smaller toys for their developing teeth, while older dogs may prefer larger toys that are easier to grip. A study by the American Veterinary Medical Association suggests that appropriate toy sizing can help prevent dental damage and encourage healthy play habits (American Veterinary Medical Association, 2021).
-
Chewing habits: A dog’s chewing style is important in determining the ideal toy size. Dogs that are aggressive chewers, such as Pit Bulls, may need tougher, larger toys. In contrast, gentle chewers, like Beagles, can manage smaller, softer toys. Research indicates that toys designed for specific chewing intensities can enhance safety and prevent damage (Pet Product News, 2022).
-
Supervised play: Regardless of size, monitoring your dog during playtime with toys is essential. This practice helps ensure your dog does not chew off and swallow any small pieces, which can pose health risks. A survey conducted by the Pet Food Industry found that 70% of pet owners reported supervising their dogs while they play with toys to ensure safety (Pet Food Industry, 2023).
By evaluating your dog’s breed, age, chewing habits, and the importance of supervision, you can select the perfect size duck toy to ensure enjoyable and safe playtime.
What Maintenance Tips Can Extend the Longevity of Duck Toys?
To extend the longevity of duck toys, proper maintenance is essential. Regular care can prevent damage and ensure safe play.
- Clean the duck toys regularly.
- Inspect for wear and tear.
- Store them in a dry place.
- Choose appropriate toys made of durable materials.
- Avoid exposure to harsh chemicals.
- Supervise playtime to prevent destruction.
Creating a routine around maintenance can significantly enhance the lifespan of duck toys.
-
Clean the Duck Toys Regularly: Cleaning duck toys regularly helps eliminate dirt, bacteria, and saliva buildup. Use mild soap and water for cleaning. The American Academy of Pediatrics suggests washing toys to reduce germs, especially for items used by children and pets.
-
Inspect for Wear and Tear: Inspecting duck toys for damage is crucial. Splits, cracks, or loose parts can pose choking hazards. The product recall system emphasizes monitoring toys frequently, ensuring safety during play.
-
Store Them in a Dry Place: Storing duck toys in a dry place preserves their integrity. Moist environments can foster mold or rot, particularly in plush or rubber toys. The CDC recommends dry storage for pet toys to maintain hygienic conditions.
-
Choose Appropriate Toys Made of Durable Materials: Selecting duck toys made of high-quality, durable materials can significantly increase longevity. Toys manufactured from non-toxic vinyl or heavy-duty rubber last longer, which a 2019 study by the Pet Industry Market outlined, showing a preference for durable, safe options.
-
Avoid Exposure to Harsh Chemicals: Harsh chemicals can degrade materials, causing them to break down faster. Using gentle cleansers and avoiding bleach or alcohol-based products can prolong the life of duck toys. Manufacturers often suggest specific cleaning methods to optimize the toy’s lifespan.
-
Supervise Playtime to Prevent Destruction: Supervising playtime helps ensure that pets do not chew apart toys. Behavioral studies indicate that monitoring pet activity can prevent destructive behaviors and enhance the enjoyment of toys, keeping them intact longer.