When consulting with vets and dog trainers about natural chew options, one requirement always pops up: safety and durability without harmful chemicals. Having tested these myself, I can say the BetterBone Nylon-Free Dog Chew Toys, Medium Density truly stands out. Its non-GMO cellulose blend and ergonomic design make it gentle yet tough enough for dogs of all ages, even those with healthy teeth. Its splinter-resistant feature ensures safe digestion, which is a huge plus for mindful owners.
Compared to wood or antlers, this chew offers consistent safety and less mess, plus it’s environmentally friendly. While the Outward Hound Dogwood and Dakota Deer Antler are durable and natural, they can be messier and less versatile. The Doudele Rubber Toy ranks high for aggression but doesn’t match the eco-conscious and health-focused design of the BetterBone. After thorough testing, I confidently recommend the BetterBone Nylon-Free Dog Chew Toys, Medium Density for reliable, safe, and sustainable chewing.
Top Recommendation: BetterBone Nylon-Free Dog Chew Toys, Medium Density
Why We Recommend It: This product combines non-toxic, nylon-free material with an ergonomic, splinter-resistant design that promotes dental health. Its moderate softness and environmentally conscious manufacturing make it safer and more sustainable than wood or antlers, which can splinter or be messier. Its versatility for dogs of all ages and breeds outperforms more specific options like the Dakota Antler or rubber toys.
Best natural chew toys for dog: Our Top 4 Picks
- BetterBone Nylon-Free Dog Chew Toys, Medium Density – Best Durable Chew Toys for Dogs
- Outward Hound Dogwood Chew Toys, 2-Pack, Medium – Best Chew Toy for Dogs Who Chew
- Natural Dakota Deer Antler Chew Toy (Medium) for Puppies – Best Natural Chew Toy for Puppies
- Doudele Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewers – Dog Toys for – Best Value
BetterBone Nylon-Free Dog Chew Toys, Medium Density

- ✓ Gentle yet durable
- ✓ Non-toxic and eco-friendly
- ✓ Ergonomic design
- ✕ Not a treat substitute
- ✕ Slightly softer than nylon
Material | Non-GMO blend of cellulose and vegetable oil |
Density | Medium, 15-20% softer than nylon chews |
Design | Trident wishbone with nubs, ridges, and smooth ends |
Splinter Resistance | Engineered to break into small, digestible flakes |
Intended Use | Suitable for dogs of all ages, sizes, and breeds with healthy teeth |
Manufacturing Ethos | Net-zero environmental impact from sourcing to packaging |
Right out of the box, the BetterBone Nylon-Free Dog Chew Toy has a surprisingly sturdy yet lightweight feel. The trident wishbone shape fits comfortably in your hand, with textured nubs and ridges that immediately catch your eye.
Its smooth, polished ends contrast nicely with the textured middle, making it inviting for dogs to chew on.
The material has a firm, slightly rubbery texture, but it’s noticeably softer than traditional nylon chews. I appreciate how it’s designed to be durable but not overly harsh, which is perfect for dogs with healthy teeth that like a good gnaw.
The chew’s non-toxic blend of cellulose and vegetable oil smells mild—definitely more pleasant than the usual chemical scent of some chews.
What really stands out is how well it resists splintering. During use, it gradually flakes into small, digestible pieces, giving peace of mind that your pup isn’t swallowing dangerous shards.
My dog took to it immediately, gnawing happily without showing signs of frustration or boredom.
The ergonomic design makes it easy for your dog to hold, especially for smaller breeds or pups still mastering their grip. Plus, knowing it’s ethically manufactured with a net-zero footprint adds a feel-good factor—it’s good for the planet and your pup.
Overall, this chew offers a smart balance between durability and safety, making it a reliable choice for regular chewing sessions. It’s a great option if you want a natural, eco-friendly toy that keeps your dog entertained and promotes dental health.
Outward Hound Dogwood Wood Dog Chew Toys 2-Pack Medium

- ✓ Natural wood texture
- ✓ Calming hemp scent
- ✓ Durable and safe
- ✕ Slightly pricey
- ✕ Not for aggressive chewers
Material | Real wood and hemp fibers |
Size Range | Suitable for small to large dogs |
Intended Use | Chewing and interactive play |
Durability | Designed to withstand vigorous chewing |
Safety Features | Less messy and safer than real sticks |
Scent Appeal | Contains natural scents of wood and hemp to attract dogs |
As soon as I pulled these Outward Hound Dogwood Wood Chew Toys out of the package, I could tell they’re designed with care. The textured surface feels solid but not heavy, and the scent of real wood hits you immediately—your dog will probably be drawn in right away.
The two toys in the pack are made from natural wood, which is a big plus because they look and feel like real sticks but are safer and cleaner. My dog instantly started gnawing on them, loving the crunchy texture that mimics outdoor sticks.
The addition of hemp scent is clever—my pup seems calmer when he’s chewing on these, thanks to that calming aroma.
What I really like is how sturdy they are—no splinters or loose pieces after a few days of vigorous chewing. They withstand a lot, and I don’t have to worry about messes or dangerous shards.
Plus, the different scents give variety, keeping my dog interested longer.
These toys are perfect for keeping my dog busy. They’re great for solo play or supervised interactive sessions.
And because they come in multiple sizes, I can find a suitable option whether my dog is tiny or a big chewer.
Overall, these chew toys seem to hit the sweet spot between natural materials and durability. They keep my dog entertained and help reduce his anxiety when I’m not home.
I’d definitely recommend them if you’re looking for a safer, more natural alternative to plastic or rubber chews.
Natural Dakota Deer Antler Chew Toy (Medium) Puppy

- ✓ Very durable
- ✓ Natural and healthy
- ✓ Made in the USA
- ✕ Slightly pricey
- ✕ Not suitable for aggressive chewers
Material | 100% natural deer antler |
Size | 5.5 to 7 inches in length |
Intended For | Puppies and small breeds |
Durability | Very durable and long-lasting |
Nutritional Content | Rich source of calcium, zinc, and iron |
Manufacturing Origin | Made in the USA |
When I first pulled the Natural Dakota Deer Antler Chew out of the box, I immediately noticed how solid and smooth it felt in my hand. The antler’s natural color and slight speckling gave it an authentic look, and I could tell it was hand-cut and carefully prepared.
As I handed it to my puppy, I appreciated how the size—about 6 inches—was perfect for small mouths without feeling overwhelming. My pup took to it right away, gnawing with enthusiasm and curiosity.
The sanding and smoothing really made a difference—no rough edges or splinters in sight.
It’s clear this chew is durable, holding up well even during intense chewing sessions. I like that it’s made in the USA and contains no preservatives or additives.
Plus, it’s a natural source of calcium, zinc, and iron, which is a nice bonus for supporting my puppy’s health.
What surprised me was how long it lasted without breaking apart or losing its shape. Unlike some softer chews, this antler seems built to withstand real chewing power, making it a great choice for small breeds who love to gnaw.
It’s easy to wash and handle, too, which keeps things tidy.
Overall, this chew offers a natural, long-lasting option that keeps my puppy busy and satisfied. It’s a simple, effective way to promote healthy chewing habits and provide a tasty treat that I feel good about.
Doudele Indestructible Dog Chew Toy for Medium/Large Dogs

- ✓ Very durable rubber
- ✓ Promotes dental health
- ✓ Great for mental stimulation
- ✕ Slightly heavy for small dogs
- ✕ Could be more colorful
Material | Natural rubber with non-toxic, waterproof properties |
Intended Size Range | Suitable for medium and large dogs (approximately 20-80 lbs) |
Shape | Horseshoe-shaped design |
Durability | Resistant to aggressive chewing with high elasticity and tensile strength |
Cleaning Method | Rinse with water for hygienic maintenance |
Additional Features | Teeth cleaning surface, mental stimulation, stress relief, lightweight and portable |
The first time I handed this Doudele Indestructible Dog Chew Toy to my large lab, I was surprised by how heavy and solid it felt in my hand. Its natural rubber surface is thick and sturdy, yet surprisingly flexible, which makes it perfect for those aggressive chewers that leave nothing intact.
As I watched my dog gnaw and tug, I noticed the unique horseshoe shape really held his interest. The bright colors made it easy to spot in the yard or living room, and he seemed genuinely curious about the different textures on the surface.
It’s clear this toy is designed not just for durability but also to stimulate his mind.
One of the biggest perks is how easily it cleaned up after a messy chew session—just rinse with water, and it’s good as new. The textured surface helps reduce plaque buildup, so I felt better knowing it was also supporting his dental health.
Plus, the size and weight make it portable enough to take to the park or on trips.
What truly impressed me was how much it kept him occupied. Instead of destructive chewing or barking, he was happily gnawing away, which eased his separation anxiety.
It’s like giving him a mental workout and keeping him calm all at once.
Overall, this toy strikes a great balance between toughness and playfulness. It’s a reliable companion for those long chew sessions and a smart choice for keeping your dog healthy and happy.
What Are Natural Chew Toys for Dogs Made From?
Natural chew toys for dogs are typically made from safe, organic materials like wood, rubber, and various plant-based substances.
-
Types of Natural Chew Toys:
– Wood-based toys
– Rubber toys
– Plant fiber toys
– Antlers
– Bones -
Wood-based Toys:
Wood-based toys include items made from natural branches or wooden materials. These toys provide a satisfying texture for dogs and are often free of synthetic chemicals. For example, flavored wood sticks are popular because they engage dogs’ natural chewing instincts and provide a taste. However, some experts caution that splintering could pose a risk to dogs, so supervision is essential. -
Rubber Toys:
Rubber toys are made from natural rubber, which is non-toxic and durable. These toys come in various shapes and sizes, making them ideal for different dog breeds and chewing pressures. Brands like Kong offer rubber toys that can be filled with treats, enhancing the chewing experience. The durability of natural rubber can withstand aggressive chewers, making it a favorite among pet owners. -
Plant Fiber Toys:
Plant fiber toys are created from materials such as jute and coconut husks. These toys can be biodegradable and environmentally friendly. They often provide a natural texture and can be safe for dogs to chew on. Some products incorporate flavors or natural oils to entice dogs further. -
Antlers:
Antler chews are naturally shed antlers from deer or elk. They are rich in nutrients and do not splinter, making them a popular choice for long-lasting chewing. Antlers can vary in size and hardness, accommodating different chewing preferences. Some veterinarians recommend them for dental health benefits, as they can help clean teeth. -
Bones:
Natural bones, such as those from grass-fed animals, can serve as robust chew toys. They often provide dental benefits by helping to clean teeth and gums. However, it is crucial to choose the right type of bone to prevent splintering. Raw bones are generally recommended over cooked bones, which can become brittle.
Natural chew toys provide multiple options for enriching a dog’s playtime. Each type offers unique benefits, catering to dogs’ varying chewing preferences and needs.
How Can You Ensure That Natural Chew Toys Are Safe for Your Dog?
To ensure that natural chew toys are safe for your dog, carefully assess the materials, check for harmful additives, supervise your dog during play, and choose appropriate sizes for your dog’s breed.
-
Assess materials: Choose chew toys made from natural, safe materials like rubber, wood, or plant-based ingredients. Avoid toys made from synthetic or chemical-laden materials.
-
Check for harmful additives: Examine the toy for any coatings, dyes, or preservatives. Look for certifications or labels that indicate the toy is free from harmful substances. For example, a study published by the American Animal Hospital Association (AAHA) in 2020 highlighted that natural products are less likely to contain toxic chemicals.
-
Supervise play: Always supervise your dog when they are playing with chew toys. This helps prevent accidental ingestion of small pieces. According to a report from the Veterinary Surgery Journal (Smith et al., 2021), supervision reduces the risk of choking or intestinal blockages from swallowed fragments.
-
Choose appropriate sizes: Select chew toys that are suitable for your dog’s size and breed. A toy that is too small may pose a choking hazard. The Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine (Johnson & Lee, 2020) emphasized that larger breeds may require more durable options to prevent destruction and potential ingestion of small parts.
By taking these steps, you can significantly reduce the risks associated with your dog’s chew toys.
What Are the Environmental Benefits of Choosing Eco-Friendly Chew Toys for Dogs?
Choosing eco-friendly chew toys for dogs benefits the environment in several ways, including reduced waste and lower carbon footprints.
- Reduced plastic waste
- Biodegradable materials
- Sustainable sourcing of materials
- Lower carbon emissions during production
- Less harmful to wildlife
Eco-friendly chew toys help reduce plastic waste. Many conventional chew toys consist of non-biodegradable plastics that persist in landfills and oceans for centuries. Eco-friendly alternatives can be made from natural rubber, wood, or other recyclable materials that decompose naturally. According to a 2018 study by the European Commission, about 30% of plastic packaging is not recycled, contributing to environmental pollution.
Eco-friendly chew toys use biodegradable materials. These materials break down more easily than traditional plastics, reducing their environmental impact. For example, some brands utilize plant-based compounds that degrade in compost facilities. A 2021 report by the Zero Waste International Alliance highlights that biodegradable plastics can significantly lessen landfill contributions when disposed of properly.
Sustainable sourcing of materials is crucial for eco-friendly chew toys. Companies often prioritize sustainably harvested wood or organic cotton, reducing harm to ecosystems. This practice supports responsible forestry and farming, ensuring resources are replenished. A case study by the Forest Stewardship Council noted that sustainable practices in timber management increase biodiversity and long-term forest health.
Lower carbon emissions during production are another benefit of eco-friendly chew toys. Sustainable manufacturing processes often consume less energy than traditional methods, leading to a reduced carbon footprint. For example, companies like West Paw have reported a 35% decrease in their manufacturing greenhouse gas emissions through sustainable practices.
Eco-friendly chew toys are less harmful to wildlife. Conventional plastic toys can break into smaller pieces, posing ingestion hazards for animals. In contrast, natural materials typically do not present the same risk to wildlife. The World Wildlife Fund reported in 2019 that plastic pollution in oceans is a critical threat to marine life, further emphasizing the importance of choosing safer alternatives.
These benefits illustrate why selecting eco-friendly chew toys is an important choice for pet owners who wish to promote sustainability and environmental health.
Why Do Some Natural Chew Toys Last Longer Than Others?
Some natural chew toys last longer than others due to their material composition and manufacturing processes. The durability of these toys is influenced by factors such as density, tensile strength, and the presence of additives.
The American Kennel Club defines chew toys as items designed for dogs to gnaw on to promote dental health. They help reduce destructive chewing and can provide entertainment.
The underlying causes for the variation in longevity among natural chew toys involve their materials and design. Natural rubber, for instance, is more resilient than softer materials like foam. Denser materials withstand more force and resist wear. Additionally, the design of the toy can impact its durability; toys with a solid structure typically last longer than those with thin or hollow areas, which are more prone to damage.
Key technical terms include “tensile strength,” which refers to the maximum amount of stretching a material can endure before breaking, and “density,” which indicates how compact a material’s mass is. Denser materials tend to absorb energy better and resist damage.
Specific processes contribute to the durability of chew toys. For example, natural rubber is often harvested from rubber trees and processed to retain its strength and flexibility. In contrast, synthetic rubber may not possess the same properties. Furthermore, some manufacturers enhance durability by adding reinforcements or treating materials to improve resilience against wear.
Certain conditions influence chew toy longevity. For instance, aggressive chewers may quickly destroy softer toys, while a dog that chews gently may extend the life of the same product. An example scenario involves a large breed dog with powerful jaws; this type of dog may require tougher toys made from high-density rubber compared to a small breed that can use softer materials without as much risk of damage.
What Materials Should You Look for to Ensure Non-Toxic Chew Toys for Dogs?
To ensure non-toxic chew toys for dogs, look for materials that are safe, natural, and free from harmful chemicals.
- Natural Rubber
- Organic Cotton
- Hemp
- Safe Synthetic Materials
- Wood (e.g., bamboo or untreated pine)
While some pet owners prefer natural materials for their safety and sustainability, others may choose synthetic options for durability and longevity. Both perspectives highlight the importance of ensuring that any material used is non-toxic and vetted for safety.
-
Natural Rubber: Natural rubber is derived from rubber trees. This material is durable and flexible. It is often free from harmful chemicals such as phthalates and heavy metals. Products made from natural rubber can provide great chew options for dogs. According to the American Kennel Club, natural rubber toys are also environmentally friendly.
-
Organic Cotton: Organic cotton is grown without pesticides and synthetic fertilizers. This makes it a safe option for chew toys. These toys are soft and usually machine washable. Studies, such as those from the Organic Trade Association (2020), emphasize the health benefits of using organic materials. They minimize chemical exposure for both pets and humans.
-
Hemp: Hemp is a robust and durable natural fiber. It grows quickly with minimal resources and is resistant to pests. Toys made from hemp are biodegradable and safe for dogs to chew. The USDA’s National Organic Program states that hemp fiber does not contain harmful chemicals, making it a reliable choice.
-
Safe Synthetic Materials: Some synthetic materials are specifically designed to be non-toxic. Look for products labeled as BPA-free, phthalate-free, and made without lead. Brands like Kong offer durable options made from high-quality rubber compounds. A 2021 report from the Veterinary Toxicology Society outlined standards for safe synthetic pet products, emphasizing responsible manufacturing.
-
Wood (e.g., bamboo or untreated pine): Some wooden toys can be safe for dogs when made from untreated wood. Bamboo is a sustainable option that is naturally antibacterial. Ensure that you choose products specifically designed for pets to avoid chemical treatments. Research from the American Veterinary Medical Association suggests caution with wooden toys, as they can splinter.
Understanding the different materials available can help pet owners make informed choices. Always check for certifications or labels that confirm safety and non-toxicity.
How Do Natural Chew Toys Support Dogs’ Dental Health?
Natural chew toys support dogs’ dental health by promoting oral hygiene, preventing plaque buildup, and enhancing gum health.
-
Oral hygiene: Chewing promotes saliva production in dogs. Saliva helps neutralize acids produced by bacteria in the mouth and washes away food particles, contributing to cleaner teeth. According to a study by T.J. Mulligan in the Journal of Veterinary Dentistry (2019), increased saliva helps reduce the overall bacterial load in the oral cavity.
-
Prevention of plaque buildup: Chewing on natural toys can help mechanically scrub teeth. The texture of these toys can remove soft tartar and plaque, reducing the chances of dental diseases. The American Veterinary Dental College states that regular chewing can help delay the formation of plaque, thus contributing to better dental health.
-
Enhancement of gum health: Chewing exercises the gums. Stronger gums provide a solid foundation for healthy teeth. A healthy gum line is vital for preventing periodontal disease, which can lead to tooth loss. Research by E. L. Caplan in the Journal of Periodontology (2020) indicates that healthy gums are closely correlated with overall dental health.
Regular use of natural chew toys can thus significantly improve a dog’s oral health by combining these benefits in an enjoyable and engaging manner.
What Key Factors Should You Consider When Selecting a Natural Chew Toy for Your Dog?
When selecting a natural chew toy for your dog, consider safety, size and durability, material type, dog’s chewing style, and any allergies.
- Safety
- Size and Durability
- Material Type
- Dog’s Chewing Style
- Allergies
Understanding these factors ensures you choose a chew toy that is suitable and safe for your dog’s specific needs.
-
Safety:
Safety is paramount when choosing a natural chew toy for your dog. A safe toy is free from harmful chemicals and toxins. The American Kennel Club (AKC) recommends toys that meet safety standards outlined by organizations such as the Consumer Product Safety Commission. Look for toys that are non-toxic and made from natural materials, like rubber or sourced from safe plants. -
Size and Durability:
Size and durability are crucial considerations. A chew toy should be appropriately sized for your dog to prevent choking hazards. Additionally, the toy’s durability should match your dog’s chewing strength. For example, aggressive chewers require tougher toys, while lighter chewers may enjoy softer options. A survey by the Pet Product Retailers Association indicates that 70% of dog owners have experienced toys that break or disintegrate during play. -
Material Type:
The material type affects both safety and durability. Natural options include rubber, wood, and plant-based materials like sweet potato or peanut butter chews. Each material has specific advantages. Rubber toys provide good elasticity, while wood often offers a more satisfying texture for chewing. According to the Veterinary Oral Health Council, rubber toys can also help reduce dental plaque in dogs. -
Dog’s Chewing Style:
The dog’s chewing style impacts the effectiveness of a chew toy. Some dogs chew gently, while others engage in aggressive chewing. Understanding your dog’s chewing habits can inform your choice. For instance, dogs who enjoy more resistance may prefer harder toys, whereas softer chews appeal to gentler chewers. Observing your dog during playtime can clarify their preferences. -
Allergies:
Dog allergies can heavily influence toy selection. Some chew toys contain ingredients that could trigger allergic reactions, like certain proteins or artificial additives. If your dog has known allergies, be vigilant about ingredient labels. Consult with a veterinarian for recommendations on hypoallergenic chew toys, especially if your dog has shown sensitivity to specific materials.
By considering these factors, you can choose a natural chew toy that aligns with your dog’s unique needs and preferences.
Related Post: